Communications Handbook for Clinical Trials: Strategies, tips, and tools to manage controversy, convey your message, and disseminate results

Acknowledgments

The Communications Handbook for Clinical Trials grew out of the collective experience of scores of individuals* who have dedicated themselves to demystifying science and ensuring that both the process and the outcomes of clinical research are communicated clearly. From the beginning, the process of creating the handbook has been a collaborative effort, and the final product reflects the wealth of this input.

The authors would especially like to thank the members of the Microbicides Media and Communications Initiative (MMCI), an ongoing “community of practice” that meets regularly to share strategies for handling the complex communications challenges posed by the conduct of large-scale effectiveness trials of HIV prevention technologies in Africa and other resource-limited settings. Many of the stories and insights contained herein derive from the experiences of MMCI members, who have been incredibly generous in sharing their knowledge, materials, and hard-won wisdom about clinical trial communication. We particularly thank all MMCI Steering Committee members (former and current): Quarraisha Abdool Karim, Centre for the AIDS Programme of Research in South Africa (CAPRISA); Manju Chatani-Gada, AVAC: Global Advocacy for Prevention; Mitzy Gafos, Microbicides Development Programme (MDP), Africa Centre; Yasmin Halima, Global Campaign for Microbicides (GCM); Polly Harrison, AVAC; Lori Heise, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine (LSHTM) (co-author); Neetha Morar, South African Medical Research Council (MRC); Oliver Mweemba, University of Zambia; Patrick Ndase, Microbicide Trials Network (MTN); Pamela Norick, International Partnership for Microbicides (IPM); Elizabeth T. Robinson, Family Health International (FHI) (co-author); Lisa Rossi, MTN; and Deborah Baron, MMCI coordinator, GCM (co-author).

A rich source of learning came from an in-person consultation that we held in March 2009, co-sponsored by the MMCI and CAPRISA. This meeting brought together 45 investigators, trial staff, and community advocates in Durban, South Africa, to solicit feedback on early drafts of the handbook and to collect examples and lessons learned from the lived experience of those working on the frontlines of communicating about HIV prevention trials in Africa. These individuals included:

Quarraisha Abdool Karim
CAPRISA
South AfricaSalim Abdool Karim
CAPRISA
South Africa

Natasha Arulappan
CAPRISA
South Africa

Nomampondo Barnabas
GCM
South Africa

Deborah Baron
MMCI/GCM
South Africa

Cheryl Baxter
CAPRISA
South Africa

Kim Best
FHI
USA

Sarah Chiduo
Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre
Tanzania

Anne Coletti
FHI
USA

Jo-Anne Collinge
Meropa/IPM
South Africa

Nozizwe Dladla-Qwabe
MRC
South Africa

Michelle Folsom
PATH
South Africa

Glenda Gray
Perinatal HIV Research Unit (PHRU)
University of the Witwatersrand
South Africa

Sarah V. Harlan
FHI
USA

Norma Hatcher
CAPRISA
South Africa

Lori L. Heise
GCM/LSHTM
USA/UK

Kenneth Kintu
Makerere University-John Hopkins University (MU-JHU) Research Collaboration
Uganda

Nadine Landsmann
MRC
South Africa

Londiwe Luthuli
CAPRISA
South Africa

Silvia Maarschalk
CAPRISA
South Africa

Leila Mansoor
CAPRISA
South Africa

William Mapham
Reproductive Health & HIV Research Unit (RHRU), University of the Witwatersrand
South Africa

Nyaradzo Mgodi
University of Zimbabwe/University of California San Francisco (UZ-UCSF)
Zimbabwe

Nkosinathi Mhlongo
Africa Centre
South Africa

Margaret Mlingo
UZ-UCSF
Zimbabwe

Neetha Morar
MRC
South Africa

Nelly Mugo
University of Nairobi
University of Washington (UW)/International Clinical Research Center (ICRC)
Kenya

Misiwe Mzimela
Africa Centre
South Africa

Kalendri Naidoo
CAPRISA
South Africa

Tarryn Naidoo
MRC
South Africa

Vivienne Naidoo
GCM
South Africa

Teopista Nakyanzi
MU-JHU Research Collaboration
Uganda

Sibusiso Nhleko
MRC
South Africa

Fanele Ntombela
CAPRISA
South Africa

Victoria Oyier
International Centre for Reproductive Health (ICRH)/IPM
Tanzania

Gita Ramjee
MRC
South Africa

Malebo Ratlhangana
Setshaba Research Centre/Medical University of Southern Africa (MEDUNSA)
South Africa

Cheri Reid
Centre for Infectious Disease Research in Zambia (CIDRZ)
Zambia

Sechele Sechele
Centers for Disease Control (CDC)/BOTUSA (Botswana-USA)
Botswana

Junaid Seedat
International AIDS Vaccine Initiative (IAVI)
South Africa

Morenike Ukpong
New HIV Vaccine and Microbicide Advocacy Society (NHVMAS)
Nigeria

Vulindlela trial participant (name withheld)
CAPRISA
South Africa

Mitchell Warren
AVAC
USA

Constancia Watadzaushe
UZ-UCSF
Zimbabwe

We are particularly grateful to the many individuals who authored case studies, shared materials, and reviewed earlier drafts of the publication. Chapters of the handbook were shared with over 80 individuals in 13 countries, and we are deeply indebted to the many individuals who provided detailed comments, research examples, and additional field experiences. This input was invaluable in making the document relevant and true to life. We would also like to thank the many individuals in Africa, Asia, Europe, North America, and South America who contributed their time and insights by agreeing to be interviewed by the authors. These interviews helped us to better understand the needs and experiences of the field and shaped both the content and structure of the final publication.

The individuals who contributed substantially to this handbook through time, materials, expert review, interviews, or authored contributions include:

Quarraisha Abdool Karim
CAPRISA
South AfricaSalim Abdool Karim
CAPRISA
South AfricaSilas Achar
FHI
KenyaKawango Agot
Impact Research and Development
Organization
KenyaLisa Marie Albert
FHI
USANomampondo Barnabas
GCM
South AfricaJonathan Baum
Consultant
USAWard Cates
FHI
USAConnie Celum
UW/ICRC
USAManju Chatani-Gada
AVAC
USALee Claypool
USAID
USAPaul Cleary
Center for Interdisciplinary Research on AIDS (CIRA)
USA

Allison Clifford
PATH
USA

Anne Coletti
FHI
USA

Jo-Anne Collinge
Meropa/IPM
South Africa

Somer Cooper
FHI
USA

Amy Corneli
FHI
USA

Sinead Delany-Moretlwe
RHRU
South Africa

Gai Doran
CIRA
USA

Samukeliso Dube
GCM
South Africa

Paul Feldblum
FHI
USA

Michelle Folsom
PATH
South Africa/USA

Anna Forbes
GCM
USA

Mitzy Gafos
MDP/Africa Centre
South Africa

Theresa Gamble
FHI
USA

Pedro Goicochea
Investigaciónes Medicas en Salud
Peru

Glenda Gray
PHRU, University of the Witwatersrand
South Africa

David Grimes
FHI
USA

James Hakim
UZ-UCSF
Zimbabwe

Daniel Halperin
Harvard University School of Public Health
USA

Sharon Hillier
MTN
USA

Jessica Justman
Mailman School of Public Health
Columbia University
USA

Kenneth Kintu
MU-JHU Research Collaboration
Uganda

Stella Kirkendale
FHI
USA

Newton Kumwenda
Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital
Malawi

Annette Larkin
CONRAD
USA

Mary Latka
AURUM Institute
South Africa

Londine Rosebud Lethuli
CAPRISA
South Africa

Natasha Mack
FHI
USA

Kathleen MacQueen
FHI
USA

Bernadette Madlala
CAPRISA
South Africa

William Mapham
RHRU, University of the Witwatersrand
South Africa

Derrick Mapp
Shanti/L.I.F.E. Institute
USA

Melissa May
Population Council
USA

Jowet Mayisela
Traditional Leader
South Africa

Vivian McLaurin
FHI
USA

Nyaradzo Mgodi
UZ-UCSF
Zimbabwe

Margaret Mlingo
UZ-UCSF
Zimbabwe

Mukelisiwe Mlotshwa
CAPRISA
South Africa

Allison Mobley
UW/ICRC
USA

Neetha Morar
MRC
South Africa

Monique Mueller
FHI
USA

Nelly Mugo
University of Nairobi and UW/ICRC
Kenya

Kennedy Mundia
MDP
Zambia

Kanya Ndaki
IRIN/Plus News Southern Africa
South Africa

Duduzile Ndouli
CAPRISA
South Africa

Kenneth Ngure
Partners in Prevention
Kenya

Pam Norick
IPM
USA

Fanelsibonge Ntombela
CAPRISA
South Africa

Gabisile Nxele
CAPRISA
South Africa

Ikoma Obunge
University of Port Harcourt Teaching Hospital
Nigeria

Lynn Paxton
CDC
USA

Leigh Peterson
FHI
USA

Deborah Phillips
PATH
USA

David Poland
MVI/PATH
USA

Eileen Quinn
PATH
USA

Bobby Ramakant
India

Gita Ramjee
MRC
South Africa

Malebo Ratlhagana
Setshaba Research Centre/MEDUNSA
South Africa

Cheri Reid
CIDRZ
Zambia

Lisa Reilly
U.S. Military HIV Research Program
USA

Janet Robinson
FHI
Thailand

Lisa Rossi
MTN
USA

Seema Sahay
National AIDS Research Institute (NARI)
India

Jorge Sanchez
Asociación Civil Impacta Salud y Educacion
Peru

Sechele Sechele
CDC/BOTUSA
Botswana

Junaid Seedat
IAVI
South Africa

Kathleen Shears
FHI
USA

Nirupama Sista
HIV Prevention Trials Network (HPTN)
USA

Dirk Taljaard
Progressus
South Africa

Roger Tatoud
MDP/Imperial College London
UK

Doug Taylor
FHI
USA

Brad Tytel
Global Health Strategies (GHS)
USA

Morenike Ukpong
NHVMAS
Nigeria

Francois Venter
RHRU, University of the Witwatersrand
South Africa

Mitchell Warren
AVAC
USA

Debra Weiner
FHI
USA

Katie West Slevin
GCM
USA

Merywen Wigley
FHI
USA

Christina Wong
FHI
USA

We extend special thanks to Sten Vermund, principal investigator of the HPTN, and Quarraisha Abdool Karim, chair of HPTN’s Information and Communication Committee, for having facilitated the review of the handbook by so many HPTN research sites.

In addition, we would like to thank the following people for their support: Sarah Alexander, HIV Vaccine Trials Network (HVTN); Lillian Anomnachi, FHI-Nigeria; Mark Aurigemma, i-PrEx; Luann Tia Blount, IPM; Allison Burns, FHI; Terry Butler, CDC; Mialy Clark, GCM; Lavinia Crawford-Browne, Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation; Alex Maiolo; Carol Manion, FHI; Carrin Martin, MRC; Timothy Mastro, FHI; Tom Milroy, consultant; Vivienne Naidoo, GCM; Patsy Norman, FHI; Bindya Patel, GCM; Scott Rose, FHI; Kenneth Schulz, FHI; Holly Seltzer, IPM; Margie Shiels, FHI; Stephanie Stuart, PATH; Monica Wanjiru, Population Council.

This handbook was produced with the generous financial support of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), via dual grants to MMCI, a project of the Global Campaign for Microbicides at PATH, and to Family Health International. Additional financial support for printing was provided by the International Partnership for Microbicides.

Finally, the authors offer a special thanks to Kathleen MacQueen for graciously opening her home in Chapel Hill, NC, to the writing team for a week-long writing retreat in 2009.

*The contributors and others acknowledged or cited in the handbook are identified by the titles they held at the time of publication in May 2010.

Credits

We acknowledge the services and creative input of the following individuals in the production of the print and online versions of the handbook:

Design and production of the online version: Deanna Ledet Saab and Jacob Reid of Design Lab 360
Editing: Michael Szpir
Additional data collection and interviewing: Mialy Clark
Writing, filming, editing and production of the video: Kim Best
Additional filming and assistance with production: Sarah Harlan
Graphic design and layout of the print version: Richard Hill/HillStudio
Production management and copyediting: Karen Dickerson
Proofreading: Kerry Aradhya
Printing: Harperprints
Administrative support: Falesha Houston, Kathy Tomasik, Vivienne Naidoo